What's new

Round 5: Dolphins vs Wests Tigers

Flip a coin for Katoa or JMK. I'm going JMK for his defence in the first half, rushing up again and again and making the tackles then the cherry on top the try he set up for Kenny B.
3. JMK
2. Katoa
1. Niko
 
Dolphins go top of the table, but at what cost?
Herbie Farnworth
 
Equaliser said:
Flip a coin for Katoa or JMK. I'm going JMK for his defence in the first half, rushing up again and again and making the tackles then the cherry on top the try he set up for Kenny B.
3. JMK
2. Katoa
1. Niko
Click to expand...
I'm going to go left-field. Katoa was able to kick how he did because the forwards were putting him in that position.
3. JMK
2. Aitken
1. Jesse Bromwich

I know it's harsh to not give Katoa a point. He had a blinder but it was a team effort. 6 or 7 players were in contention for one of the best.
 
Red said:
Is that better or worse than a torn pec? I think a partially torn pec is about half a season but a torn pec is the season so I guess an AC joint injury can't be any worse than a torn pec.
Click to expand...
I'm not an orthopedic surgeon but I think it's better. Because as you said, a torn pec is season over but an AC joint injury could go either way. It could mean a Gilbert style reco or it could mean a month on the sideline. Though admittedly, the best case scenario is doubtful. If he's back this season, that will be a bonus.
 
Red said:
Is that better or worse than a torn pec? I think a partially torn pec is about half a season but a torn pec is the season so I guess an AC joint injury can't be any worse than a torn pec.
Click to expand...
yeah if its on bad side he need op
 
sounds like Kaufusi out a week thom be fine
Kurt Donoghoe on report be intresting too
 
Just caught up on the game. Was up near Liverpool this morning. Wallet firmly locked safe.

First up. Jack. He had a very good game, however yet again was caught 20m in field and gave up their first try. He needs to stick to his channel. Otherwise I was actually impressed with him. I know I've given him alot of shit but he is definitely improving.

Katoa was playing 5 years ahead of last year. Calm, good kick variation, maybe lacks a little wider vision.

Kenny, where did that sprint come from. Val could do that if there was a bargain bucket up for grabs.

Herbie looks bad. An AC is bad news been there done that. If he's popped it it could be the best outcome if he's ruptured the bursa or cartilage it's nasty.

Stone consistent

Jmk, nothing like sticking it to Benji.

Hammer was on top form.

Kodi. It's like watching scrappy doo.

Felice, I thought was quiet until his beautiful run shame it ended his night.

Nobody had a crap game. That makes me happy.
 
Red said:
Is that better or worse than a torn pec? I think a partially torn pec is about half a season but a torn pec is the season so I guess an AC joint injury can't be any worse than a torn pec.
Click to expand...
6-12 weeks recovery, if no surgery.

I am no medical professional though
 
mr_c said:
lol props in qld cup were destroying val with speed
Click to expand...
Really? You have a habit of wildly talking up certain players and doing the opposite with others.
 
Gary said:
Hoping they move Aitken back to centre, bring Wallace to the bench , stone to start
Click to expand...
Aitken has been killing it in the backrow. For that reason, I wouldn't move him.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Community platform by XenForo® © 2010-2024 XenForo Ltd.
Top