Round 23: Dolphins vs Newcastle Knights

[Dolph]

But still against the rules. dying mins important plays you do not give them the chance to take it off you

Disagree. In the heat of combat, these things happen. There was nothing in it. That's the way I see it anyway and that is also how the refs boss sees it.

 

[midlands hobo]

1)Disagree. 2)In the heat of combat, these things happen. 3)There was nothing in it.

1)Agree to disagree. I'm not saying it was a good call.
2) they do happen but it's called discipline
3) if there is nothing in it why do it. It was a stupid thing to do and let's face it on Replay not exactly discrete.

If it was reversed and they had been in our situation and scored to win we would all be screaming penalty. How many times have the bunker reviewed a call but picked up a penalty in the background and called that instead.

 

[Dolph]

1)Agree to disagree. I'm not saying it was a good call.
2) they do happen but it's called discipline
3) if there is nothing in it why do it. It was a stupid thing to do and let's face it on Replay not exactly discrete.

If it was reversed and they had been in our situation and scored to win we would all be screaming penalty. How many times have the bunker reviewed a call but picked up a penalty in the background and called that instead.

1. Agree
2. They not only happen but happen all the time. If there's nothing in it, play on.
3. Have you never done anything in the heat of battle you later regretted?

Disagree. If the roles had been reversed and they scored, I very much doubt anyone would have even noticed that because it didn't effect the play in any way. That's the crux of the situation. If that penalty hadn't been blown, no one would have noticed it.

 

[Equaliser]

1. Agree
2. They not only happen but happen all the time. If there's nothing in it, play on.
3. Have you never done anything in the heat of battle you later regretted?

Disagree. If the roles had been reversed and they scored, I very much doubt anyone would have even noticed that because it didn't effect the play in any way. That's the crux of the situation. If that penalty hadn't been blown, no one would have noticed it.

1. Agree
2. They not only happen but happen all the time. If there's nothing in it, play on.
3. Have you never done anything in the heat of battle you later regretted?

Disagree. If the roles had been reversed and they scored, I very much doubt anyone would have even noticed that because it didn't effect the play in any way. That's the crux of the situation. If that penalty hadn't been blown, no one would have noticed it.

Stop the fight. The final word is you are both right.
1. There was nothing in it.
2. He shouldn't have done it anyway.
3. The ref was wrong to blow a penalty.

 

[Dolph]

Stop the fight. The final word is you are both right.
1. There was nothing in it.
2. He shouldn't have done it anyway.
3. The ref was wrong to blow a penalty.

I think we all agree. Just to what extent. I just think as you said there was nothing in it. Because there was nothing in it, I can't criticise Herman at all.