10. DOLPHINS — B-
In just their second ever season, there weren’t many giving Wayne Bennett’s Dolphins a chance of qualifying for the finals. After 15 rounds, when the NRL’s newest side sat fourth, those doubters certainly had egg on their face. Yet, after 27 rounds, the egg has been washed, with Bennett’s side’s late season capitulation resulting in them losing narrowly to the Knights and stumbling at the final top eight hurdle. The Dolphins won just three of their last 11 games to go from top four hopefuls to ninth-placed headscratchers, wondering how they let their first shot at finals football slip through their fingers. Some will argue Bennett’s deal to re-join the South Sydney Rabbitohs as head coach, signed at the end of May, distracted the super coach and led to the Dolphins’ demise, but there were other factors at play. Injuries certainly didn’t help, with several stars missing chunks of the season. While Bennett’s time at the club is up, several of the club’s key performers this season are young and hungry for success, namely Isaiaya Katoa, Hamiso Tabuai-Fidow and Herbie Farnworth. A missed opportunity to make the finals will be rued, though there are definite solid foundations for the club’s future to be built off.
Seems fair. Aitken was a bigger loss than he's given credit for.