What's new

2025 Squad

mr_c said:
any numbers could have a poor season will they rubbish them they just make bs dumb excuses
Click to expand...
I don't have a problem with your love for SOS but putting down a genuine star in the making, Katoa, in order to promote SOS is uncalled for.
 
Josh said:
I don't have a problem with your love for SOS but putting down a genuine star in the making, Katoa, in order to promote SOS is uncalled for.
Click to expand...
Katoa comes on the market tomorrow he gets most clubs chasing him with big offers led by Gould and Politis.

O'Sullivan is looking likely as England, Newcastle or backup halfback.
 
Josh said:
I don't have a problem with your love for SOS but putting down a genuine star in the making, Katoa, in order to promote SOS is uncalled for.
Click to expand...
where have i put him down and why is it ok to do it to other players
show me the post ?
 
Josh said:
Where have you put Katoa down? In every second post last year.
Click to expand...

umm you accuse me of things i never said , if you say i do these things show me instead of accusing someone ,

because no where in my posts have i done that
 
mr_c said:
umm you accuse me of things i never said , if you say i do these things show me instead of accusing someone ,

because no where in my posts have i done that
Click to expand...
  1. I'm not accusing you. You are entitled to like or dislike whatever players you want. Just saying your talking up a SOS at the expense of Katoa rubs people the wrong way. I think you are the only person in the universe, maybe apart from SOS's dad, who thinks he is better than Katoa. Should just say SOS is awesome, not that Katoa is sh*t.
  2. I don't know if you said Katoa was sh*t or not. I can't remember what you actually stated but I know last year you were constantly talking down Katoa and talking up SOS.
  3. Once again, it's fine by me. I just disagree. But it annoys some people.
 
Josh said:
  1. I'm not accusing you. You are entitled to like or dislike whatever players you want. Just saying your talking up a SOS at the expense of Katoa rubs people the wrong way. I think you are the only person in the universe, maybe apart from SOS's dad, who thinks he is better than Katoa. Should just say SOS is awesome, not that Katoa is sh*t.
  2. I don't know if you said Katoa was sh*t or not. I can't remember what you actually stated but I know last year you were constantly talking down Katoa and talking up SOS.
  3. Once again, it's fine by me. I just disagree. But it annoys some people.
Click to expand...
again going say it again, i never said he was shit , never said sully was better , i have always ben concerned that the kid is young he could go anyway in his career

so josh again dont come here accusing me of stuff i never said

even you said" i dont know if i said it ffs i either said it or i didnt ( accusing me )"




no player deserves disrespect , and i never said anything disrespectful like what has said about sully

you have no right to acusse me without proof

this stops now


sick of walking on eggshells just because got different views but now to be accussed of things you got problem do it in private
 
Last edited:
Josh said:
  1. I'm not accusing you. You are entitled to like or dislike whatever players you want. Just saying your talking up a SOS at the expense of Katoa rubs people the wrong way. I think you are the only person in the universe, maybe apart from SOS's dad, who thinks he is better than Katoa. Should just say SOS is awesome, not that Katoa is sh*t.
  2. I don't know if you said Katoa was sh*t or not. I can't remember what you actually stated but I know last year you were constantly talking down Katoa and talking up SOS.
  3. Once again, it's fine by me. I just disagree. But it annoys some people.
Click to expand...
I'm sure you're right Josh some will argue for the sake of arguing you can post up an apple and one will call it a kit kat.

O'Sullivan is off contract and only has one club interested being Bulldogs and we don't even know if Gould has tabled an offer and he will have the backdrop of Newcastle if all else fails.

Katoa wasn't on the market last year as he was still locked in for 2025 and was already attracting huge interest before Woolf locked him down long term.

I like Sean O'Sullivan as a person he's one of those real good blokes but as a footballer he has a limited ceiling point.

Katoa who's also a terrific person met him once and you watch him on interviews just really humble and switched on person and as a footballer the sky is the absolute limit.
 
mr_c said:
again going say it again, i never said he was shit , never said sully was better , i have always ben concerned that the kid is young he could go anyway in his career

so josh again dont come here accusing me of stuff i never said

even you said" i dont know if i said it ffs i either said it or i didnt ( accusing me )"




no player deserves disrespect , and i never said anything disrespectful like what has said about sully

you have no right to acusse me without proof

this stops now


sick of walking on eggshells just because got different views but now to be accussed of things you got problem do it in private
Click to expand...
As I said, I don't know the exact words you used.

Anyway, this year Katoa is going to cement himself as one of the premier halves in the competition and unless Katoa is injured, SOS won't see the NRL. At least not with the Dolphins. Good like to him. I have nothing against him. He tried really hard for the Dolphins and was much better than I thought he would be this time in 2023. But now is Katoa's time and there is only room for one of them in the 17.
 
Josh said:
As I said, I don't know the exact words you used.

Anyway, this year Katoa is going to cement himself as one of the premier halves in the competition and unless Katoa is injured, SOS won't see the NRL. At least not with the Dolphins. Good like to him. I have nothing against him. He tried really hard for the Dolphins and was much better than I thought he would be this time in 2023. But now is Katoa's time and there is only room for one of them in the 17.
Click to expand...
Agree with you on Katoa and O'Sullivan.

I really believe Donoghue will see plenty of time in the 17 this year. Many here don't like him he's one of my favourites and has 20 screws loose which I like even more but his time is now as well. Plath said on a podcast recently that Woolf is a massive Donoghue fan.
 
Josh said:
As I said, I don't know the exact words you used.

Anyway, this year Katoa is going to cement himself as one of the premier halves in the competition and unless Katoa is injured, SOS won't see the NRL. At least not with the Dolphins. Good like to him. I have nothing against him. He tried really hard for the Dolphins and was much better than I thought he would be this time in 2023. But now is Katoa's time and there is only room for one of them in the 17.
Click to expand...
then your just accusing me when you dont actually know what i said
 
mr_c said:
then your just accusing me when you dont actually know what i said
Click to expand...
I'm not "accusing you". Say and think whatever you want about whichever player you want.
 
257Matt said:
Agree with you on Katoa and O'Sullivan.

I really believe Donoghue will see plenty of time in the 17 this year. Many here don't like him he's one of my favourites and has 20 screws loose which I like even more but his time is now as well. Plath said on a podcast recently that Woolf is a massive Donoghue fan.
Click to expand...
5/8 is his spot. He definitely isn't a hooker.
 
to be honest i think kurt be much needed in cup side as leaves us with not much experience i think we see him in second row where he be on weekend there everything i seen of him this season hes been in forwards
 
Josh said:
5/8 is his spot. He definitely isn't a hooker.
Click to expand...
Utility is Donga's best spot and he's the best Utility in the club because he can cover a wider range of positions.

If there was one spot where Donga is strongest at it would be 5/8 and it's a four way shoot out to partner Katoa in the halves with Averillo in front.
 
i reckon if club wanted him as half n see him in forwards i say thats where we see him
 
257Matt said:
Utility is Donga's best spot and he's the best Utility in the club because he can cover a wider range of positions.

If there was one spot where Donga is strongest at it would be 5/8 and it's a four way shoot out to partner Katoa in the halves with Averillo in front.
Click to expand...
Kodi is probably the best utility in the NRL.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Community platform by XenForo® © 2010-2024 XenForo Ltd.
Top