What's new

Round 24: Dolphins vs Manly Sea Eagles

Red said:
They are pretty good when starting as well. Don't you think the touch football game against the Broncos has warped the view of a lot of people regarding the "devastating impact" Donoghue and Plath have? In previous weeks against better teams and against the last placed team, they didn't have any kind of standout "impact". Both were good but in hindsight, I'm almost certain the team would have been better if one of the two was starting at lock.
Click to expand...


warped the view of who most media they been all over our bench impact since we started that winning run , and i dont see the change team just to get one them starting unless injurys they know there job n do it well woolf uses that strength
 
Last edited:
Red said:
They are pretty good when starting as well. Don't you think the touch football game against the Broncos has warped the view of a lot of people regarding the "devastating impact" Donoghue and Plath have? In previous weeks against better teams and against the last placed team, they didn't have any kind of standout "impact". Both were good but in hindsight, I'm almost certain the team would have been better if one of the two was starting at lock.
Click to expand...
You cannot have too much stand out impact when the whole team has turned around and bent over.
 
Red said:
If you don't rate every Dolphins player, you aren't a fan...... apparently. Do you think Knowles is going better than Plath and Donoghue?
⅜
I don't think I'm either. Why do you think I am?
Click to expand...
Lol plath nearly had much games as Kurt pretty hard to compare ( like everyone that goes out there they go out there knowing the role they play not the position
why aactually do you follow this team most us are here for whole team the coaches the other team lol very few fans sit there n need rate players over a beer lol

Just read your comments champ you get your answers why woolf aint changing to what you want go listen to plath and kurt they love doing what they do
 
Last edited:
Red said:
If you don't rate every Dolphins player, you aren't a fan...... apparently. Do you think Knowles is going better than Plath and Donoghue?

I don't think I'm either. Why do you think I am?
Click to expand...
If you don’t rate Knowles you’re not a fan….

But if you don’t rate Donoghoe you’re still a fan hahahahaha

Last night Cleary got exposed for not having Yeo next to him. Will Katoa step up not having Dongohoe next to him? Katoa change in form this year coincided when Donga returned.
 
257Matt said:
If you don’t rate Knowles you’re not a fan….

But if you don’t rate Donoghoe you’re still a fan hahahahaha

Last night Cleary got exposed for not having Yeo next to him. Will Katoa step up not having Dongohoe next to him? Katoa change in form this year coincided when Donga returned.
Click to expand...
thats why its a team sport , and they all got each others back ( next man syndrome) yeah losses happen get over it chocks played some hughe footy so did panthers
 
midlands hobo said:
You cannot have too much stand out impact when the whole team has turned around and bent over.
Click to expand...
True. Why does the team do that when Plath and Donoghue are off the field? As they are both locks, why not always have one on?
 
Red said:
True. Why does the team do that when Plath and Donoghue are off the field? As they are both locks, why not always have one on?
Click to expand...
because you put the pyscial team on first then you put on the guys that clean up the scraps


you going have big fast bodys at start of game ( are likes of plath n krt going make same impact from start in big games against the big guys who will be full of engery as we previously said inpact happens when bodies are tierd
 
mr_c said:
because you put the pyscial team on first then you put on the guys that clean up the scraps


you going have big fast bodys at start of game ( are likes of plath n krt going make same impact from start in big games against the big guys who will be full of engery as we previously said inpact happens when bodies are tierd
Click to expand...
Yeah, cause Plath and Donoghue are like little girls. No physical presence at all.
 
Red said:
Yeah, cause Plath and Donoghue are like little girls. No physical presence at
Click to expand...


why change things they prove they the best impact players in the comp ( dont think any our other bench players going come anywhere near as good those two dont think your really thought about it to much what they are actually used for which makes it so special for them team once you work that out you wont need question why they do it with both


Brian Pouniu i loved to see off the bench in nrl in forwarfs has some wheels in both forwarfs n backs
 
Last edited:
Don't forget the game this evening.

Dolphins by 14
FTS - Herbie
MOTM - Plath
 
Not only do we have 3/4 locks. Yeo is an 80 minute lock.

Plath and Kurt woukd be fine for the squad in total. Rotating them is a luxury. If one got injured im sure thr other could go close to 80mins.

Its puzzling
 
Liverbird with Phins up said:
Not only do we have 3/4 locks. Yeo is an 80 minute lock.

Plath and Kurt woukd be fine for the squad in total. Rotating them is a luxury. If one got injured im sure thr other could go close to 80mins.

Its puzzling
Click to expand...
If Saifiti wasn't medically retired, which was after Knowles was recruited, Gilbert would've also been a lock.
 
Josh said:
Dolphins by 4 (They are going to be fired up)
FTS - Knowles Lemuelu
MOTM - Knowles Kodi
Click to expand...
I've never said Knowles is bad or not rated him, I've just said Plath or Donoghue should be the starting lock and if available, one of them should be on the field at all times.
  • Dolphins by 16
  • FTS - Bostock
  • MoM - Donoghue
 
Red said:
I've never said Knowles is bad or not rated him, I've just said Plath or Donoghue should be the starting lock and if available, one of them should be on the field at all times.
  • Dolphins by 16
  • FTS - Bostock
  • MoM - Donoghue
Click to expand...
then derives the point of having them as bench impact which they good at ( it would leave us with not very strong speed wise bench )
 
Last edited:
Red said:
I've never said Knowles is bad or not rated him, I've just said Plath or Donoghue should be the starting lock and if available, one of them should be on the field at all times.
  • Dolphins by 16
  • FTS - Bostock
  • MoM - Donoghue
Click to expand...
I'm the one who said he was bad and the stats prove that. He is the least ranked amongst all NRL forwards in tackle efficiency and metres gained. He is a tough nut, I'll give him that, but he is totally out of his element as a NRL player.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Community platform by XenForo® © 2010-2024 XenForo Ltd.
Top