Liverbird with Phins up
Pod Origin Rep
- Joined
- Apr 27, 2023
- Messages
- 2,351
That series is precisely what I was referencing. How it opened my eyes to the chaos of the game before professionalism I could hardly believe. Yet again glad our admin has been smooth.Rugby League Digest did an amazing series on the Super League War so comprehensive and went deep into so many clubs including dedicated chapter to how Souths were run prior to them being kicked out and done a two part series on Gold Coast, a two part series on Peter Moore (Bulldogs CEO) and even a chapter on the Crushers. It was very compelling and comprehensive.
Hmmmm they all "want to stay" but not putting pen to paper. Every successful team has to shed players. I think we are going to lose one of Hammer, Herbie or Jack.![]()
'Hammer and Herbie Show' far from Phinished yet
Dolphins duo Hamiso Tabuai-Fidow and Herbie Farnworth have forged a lethal liaison they both hope will blossom further as they approach career-defining moments.aapnews.aap.com.au
Promising article today it seems like both Herbie and Hammer want to stay at the Dolphins
If we can get them and Bostock all done before Nov 1 it's basically perfect as far as retention and recruitment goes for this year then the remainder are optional until next year with Katoa/Plath/Donoghoe/JMK if he's still playing at the same level he is now
i would highly doubt it , for the 1 reason most clubs wont afford them n we would want something of that value backHmmmm they all "want to stay" but not putting pen to paper. Every successful team has to shed players. I think we are going to lose one of Hammer, Herbie or Jack.
I think we lose Flegler, and JMK.Hmmmm they all "want to stay" but not putting pen to paper. Every successful team has to shed players. I think we are going to lose one of Hammer, Herbie or Jack.
4 of the Dolphins 5 most valuable players are off contract end of 2028.I tend to agree Flegler's the one that is surplus to needs and we need that cap space
and yeah of the biggest four off contract next year Katoa needs an upgrade but has already basically said he's staying then we absolutely need to upgrade and prioritise Plath and Donoghoe as our two best middles and while JMK is amazing he'll be approaching the end of his prime so either 1-2 year extensions or if we need someone to make way it might be him especially if we have another 9 good to go (i'm not sure how Jordan Plath is developing as I haven't watched a ton of QCup this year but if it's going well getting him into first grade presumably also means it's easier to keep Max)
I think if Liverbird is right and we lose Flegler, JMK and Knowles (plus Kaufusi to retire when his deal expires) plus the players we're already let go and retain everyone else we should have enough cap space to do that if we don't sign anyone else other than cheapish middle forwards for depth if we need them and otherwise promote our up and comers to the top 30 for depth players
We could also afford to lose Lemuelu if need be as much as i'd like to keep him as long as we have Pouniu extended beforehand, or vice versa if Lemuelu stays although I assume Pouniu will be the one we prioritise keeping
If we have a 1-7 that looks like Hammer, Naufahu, Bostock, Herbie, Cobbo, Williams, Katoa, then keep Plath and Donoghoe (and Molo is already signed) plus Finefuiaki and one of Pouniu or Lemuelu, we can fill in the gaps around that fairly easily with the existing players we have being developed and the other players we manage to keep that are already on the roster
I think JMK has at least 2 or 3 good years after this one.4 of the Dolphins 5 most valuable players are off contract end of 2028.
Katoa isn't anywhere near the prime of his career, Plath and Donoghoe probably hit their prime next year and JMK will be winding down.
2 more good years brings him to 2028 when it's contract expiry time. He'll be winding down by that stage.I think JMK has at least 2 or 3 good years after this one.
Bulldogs made a huge mistake letting him go. Was that also Phil Gould's doing?2 more good years brings him to 2028 when it's contract expiry time. He'll be winding down by that stage.
Gould cut JMK with a year to go on his contract to sign Reed Mahoney.Bulldogs made a huge mistake letting him go. Was that also Phil Gould's doing?
Yes, he wanted the grub. Who he punted, for the current shit cunt. Who he is going to punt for the next shit cunt he thinks is the dogs bollocks. Who he will punt.Bulldogs made a huge mistake letting him go. Was that also Phil Gould's doing?
You know you can rent. Probably extra 100 a week.I told you. Theyll all stsy. Stop worrying.
From a money stand point it makes no sense to move from brisbane. It costs you much more thrn 300k extra to leave brisbane. Let alone adding stamp duty and taxes.
Then lifestyle and weather.
The only club is the Broncos. Woolf was approached to takeover from madge hence the resigning. No point going there. Dolphins is the place to be in brissy.
Again. Theyll all stay.
You have to play for 10 years to break even at that rate.You know you can rent. Probably extra 100 a week.

The Dolphins Pod is a fan forum made and maintained by Dolphins fans; and has no official affiliation with The Dolphins NRL Club.