What's new

Search results

  1. Red

    Round 24: Dolphins vs Manly Sea Eagles

    I do in hindsight as well but at the time, thought it's better to go for a try.
  2. Red

    Round 24: Dolphins vs Manly Sea Eagles

    Is Donoghue so important to the attack? TBH, it hasn't been a great game so far. First half standouts: Fin JMK Hammer
  3. Red

    Round 24: Dolphins vs Manly Sea Eagles

    No, no. no! Had to keep the ball and go for a try instead of taking the 2.
  4. Red

    Round 24: Dolphins vs Manly Sea Eagles

    We can't buy a set restart.
  5. Red

    Round 24: Dolphins vs Manly Sea Eagles

    Bostock is a better winger than centre.
  6. Red

    Round 24: Dolphins vs Manly Sea Eagles

    I didn't know he was going that badly. I just knew the team is much better when Plath or Donoghue is the lock.
  7. Red

    Round 24: Dolphins vs Manly Sea Eagles

    I've never said Knowles is bad or not rated him, I've just said Plath or Donoghue should be the starting lock and if available, one of them should be on the field at all times. Dolphins by 16 FTS - Bostock MoM - Donoghue
  8. Red

    Round 24: Dolphins vs Manly Sea Eagles

    Yeah, cause Plath and Donoghue are like little girls. No physical presence at all.
  9. Red

    Round 24: Dolphins vs Manly Sea Eagles

    True. Why does the team do that when Plath and Donoghue are off the field? As they are both locks, why not always have one on?
  10. Red

    Round 24: Dolphins vs Manly Sea Eagles

    If you don't rate every Dolphins player, you aren't a fan...... apparently. Do you think Knowles is going better than Plath and Donoghue? I don't think I'm either. Why do you think I am?
  11. Red

    Round 24: Dolphins vs Manly Sea Eagles

    They are pretty good when starting as well. Don't you think the touch football game against the Broncos has warped the view of a lot of people regarding the "devastating impact" Donoghue and Plath have? In previous weeks against better teams and against the last placed team, they didn't have any...
  12. Red

    Round 24: Dolphins vs Manly Sea Eagles

    Ok. So why can't Knowles come on and have "impact" instead? Because the team is way better when at least one of Plath or Donoghue is on.
  13. Red

    Round 24: Dolphins vs Manly Sea Eagles

    Why is it that those 2 only have "impact" when coming off the bench (usually with us behind)? Why can't they have "impact" from the first seconds?
  14. Red

    Round 24: Dolphins vs Manly Sea Eagles

    So the coach is infallible. Got it. Are you a supporter of the team or just the coach?
  15. Red

    Round 24: Dolphins vs Manly Sea Eagles

    💯 I don't want to sack the coach either. But what he is doing regarding not starting with Plath or Donoghue and hiring the 30 something English halfback to play 5/8 is confusing me greatly. I'm not a fan of either of these things. He's done ok with the team Wayne and SOS left him. His big...
  16. Red

    Round 24: Dolphins vs Manly Sea Eagles

  17. Red

    Round 24: Dolphins vs Manly Sea Eagles

    In his first 2 seasons I was highly critical of Donoghue. He was playing poorly on the odd occasion he was playing at all. Last year he was our best and this year he is neck and neck with Plath and Herbie. Plath or Donoghue should be on the field at all times if available.
  18. Red

    Round 24: Dolphins vs Manly Sea Eagles

    So I'm wrong for criticising the coach and wrong for advocating letting Stone go, which the coach has done. Got it. I rate Stone. Always have. Rate Knowles as well. Just don't rate them as much as Plath or Donoghue. Do you think the team is better with Knowles at lock or with Plath or Donoghue...
  19. Red

    Round 24: Dolphins vs Manly Sea Eagles

    Were you satisfied with going behind 24-0 vs the second from bottom team? It was almost 28 or 30-0. Just barely beat last place the week before. I wasn't sure what the problem was. I rated Knowles. I still do but to a lesser extent after I read a comment here pointing out his stats. His lack of...
  20. Red

    Round 24: Dolphins vs Manly Sea Eagles

    I think an assistant should have already asked the question but one is his brother and one is a dude called Dave Elliott. I don't know anything about him but he's probably just a yes-man for Woolf.
Community platform by XenForo® © 2010-2024 XenForo Ltd.
Top