What's new

Recruitment and Retention for 2028

I don't get this starting assurance thing

60 minutes at lock is 60 minutes at lock regardless of whether it's minues 0-60, 0-20 and 40-80 or 20-80 it isn't 1983 here, star players start on the bench all the time as long as they get full minutes, Harry Grant did it for years, David Fifita did it, etc

JMK is irreplaceable now (well not irreplaceable, Harry Grant is on the market, although I doubt we can afford him unless we lose both centres) but may not be by the end of his contract

Plath and Donoghoe will need upgrades and obviously Katoa will need to be bumped up to at least 1.2m a season or so which is a big upgrade but only 600k or so vs what he's on now if he's willing to take a big salary but slight unders to keep the side together which he's talked about repaying loyalty a lot, obviously we should not low ball him at all but he is pretty likely to extend on 1.2-1.3m a season vs trying to get 1.5+ on the open market especially if we are in a contending window

Williams 800k will be coming back into the cap too by 2029 unless he's getting extended for delivering at an elite level still and at his age will likely be 1-2 year deals max so there's a chance we can move Dongohoe to 6 and not have to sign a replacement at that point if we don't have a ready made developed talent to promote whether that's Oloapu or whoever else if we want to keep Donoghoe primarily at lock and Plath primarily as a middle forward.

Molo will also be off contract/probably not re signed due to age at that point and will be replaced by a rookie most likely, so that's a small saving there as well as well as Kaufusi retiring

If we keep both Bostock and Herbie it does make the cap very tight but if Bostock and Flegler both move on as expected we should have more than enough cap room to keep Herbie and then keep all of Katoa/Plath/Donoghoe/JMK next year - as good as JMK is I can't imagine there will be an enormous market for him on huge money given he will be 33 at the start of the 2029 season, he'll be fine to play on but probably on one year at a time deals etc and not on a huge salary increase given his age

If we somehow keep both Bostock and Herbie we could probably free up some cap space by not re-signing Fuller and using Herbie as a backup fullback since we'll have cover at centre and i'd imagine that would squeeze Williams out after his current deal and either Donoghoe could go to five-eighth and Plath back to lock or we end up with a rookie five eighth for the 2029 season which gives us tons of time to develop one.

There's a very good chance we are a very attractive club for talent to stay with or land at after the 2027 season as even if we do lose Bostock and/or Herbie we still have them for this season and with our squad we should probably finish top 4 if we stay healthy and be competing to win a premiership.
If molo is a club man, which he seems to be for us, I reckon we keep him long as he is ok with his pay. Dude has earned it.

Also be interesting to lose Jack and gain Best considering he is one of the only other centres I would actually want, and with woolfy's record of developing players he could go to another level. Would be the toughest centre pairing to defend if one hit up and tackle break from Herbie was followed by a power run from best. Then if kuli is trucking along in the front row Jesus Christ we've somehow gotten stronger
 
If molo is a club man, which he seems to be for us, I reckon we keep him long as he is ok with his pay. Dude has earned it.

Also be interesting to lose Jack and gain Best considering he is one of the only other centres I would actually want, and with woolfy's record of developing players he could go to another level. Would be the toughest centre pairing to defend if one hit up and tackle break from Herbie was followed by a power run from best. Then if kuli is trucking along in the front row Jesus Christ we've somehow gotten stronger.
This will be his last contract. He still has this year and next. But he's definitely been better than Flegler.
 
World Cup is over

Hopefully we get some retention news on Herbie and ideally on Bostock too

and Flegler to the Cowboys (I guess for 2028 unless we have a replacement ready but it's not a huge disaster to let him go early, if we free the cap space we can maybe front-load someone's contract in 2027)
 
If molo is a club man, which he seems to be for us, I reckon we keep him long as he is ok with his pay. Dude has earned it.

Also be interesting to lose Jack and gain Best considering he is one of the only other centres I would actually want, and with woolfy's record of developing players he could go to another level. Would be the toughest centre pairing to defend if one hit up and tackle break from Herbie was followed by a power run from best. Then if kuli is trucking along in the front row Jesus Christ we've somehow gotten stronger
When I was looking at my best 1-19 I really wanted Kuli 10 and Pouniu 11 and still believe this is the way to go.
 
fin aint no full time prop ( dont really care what he done in world cup ) and i would say Pouniu will be 12 if needed looking at the games he plays at qld cup level at 2nd row
 
I would much rather have Bostock and Herbie in the side and pay a rookie forward the minimum than have Utoikumanu on close to a million

I'd absolutely be interested in Utoikumanu but he is not the marquee player that takes a team's pack to dominating

If we're spending the Flegler money on a prop and could get Moses Leota right now, then sure, absolutely - but Stefano even though he's good isn't that guy and by the time Leota will be available he'll be too old to pay marquee money for.

Sua probably gets the low minutes Flegler job done well enough if we also shift Plath into the middle for most of his minutes and he just does 20 at lock and Donoghoe does 60 at lock and then we can potentially see if Finefuiaki or Lemuelu (probably Finefuiaki) can switch to the middle to accommodate Pouniu and boost our pack as well

The Storm forward pack was outright horrific this year to the point their elite spine couldn't even do anything. I'd probably rather Safiti, Willison or Leota if we were going after a marquee middle but Leota and Safiti are age risks obviously, I think it makes more sense we develop our existing middles and have a truly spectacular 1-7, the Knights probably win the comp with that model with their starting halfback injured this year if Safiti and Mooney hadn't also been injured for the final, they only lost by 1 with both of their best props out and with an obviously weak forward pack for a grand final side.

If we can get Stefano on 600k a season then absolutely but I have a feeling he'll get closer to 1m a season and that is a disaster for what you're getting imo

Assuming we stay healthy and Flegler does secure an early release, i'd have our middles look something like

8. Gilbert and 10. Su'a and 13. Plath (for first 20 minutes, Donoghoe plays 60mins lock)

When we roll subs, Donoghoe comes on for Plath and goes to lock for the rest of the game for the impact that worked so well in 2026 playing 60mins there, Molo comes on for Gilbert to keep an experienced middle out there and Finefuiaki/Lemuelu come on for Su'a (if either can work as a middle)

so our middles look something like 8. Molo 10. Finefuiaki and 13. Donoghoe

When we roll subs again, Plath comes back as soon as possible and goes to prop to do the max minutes he's capable of I assume 60ish, Finefuiaki slides out to second row to play 60ish mins and whichever second rower needs to come off to accommodate out of Lemuelu and Pouniu comes off

So then we have 8. Molo, 10 Plath, 13 Donoghoe for a while

Then Molo subs off for Gilbert's second stint so they've done ~45mins for Gilbert and ~35mins for Molo at prop having one on at all times

So then the middle is 8. Gilbert 10 Plath 13 Donoghoe for the rest of the game unless injury/fatigue means we either need to bring Su'a back for a second stint or use our unused bench forward or Finefuaki more middle mins and both second rowers play 80

We could also switch roles with Molo starting and finishing and Gilbert doing the middle portion of the game, whichever rotation the coach thinks is better.

So our side looks like

I think that's a pretty damn amazing side at full strength without having to add a middle AND that's with having let Flegler go early, obviously he gets a spot still if he's staying one more year - so it would look something like

1. Hammer
2. Cobbo
3. Herbie
4. Bostock
5. Naufahu
6. Williams
7. Katoa
8. Gilbert/Molo (they play exactly 80 between them)
9. JMK
10. Su'a (plays one 20-25min stint for now)
11. Lemuelu
12. Pouniu
13. Plath (20 at lock, 40ish at prop)

14. Fineganofo (or Schneider if he isn't ready) to cover halves and hooker
15. Gilbert/Molo (they play exactly 80 between them)
16. Finefuiaki (plays ~55mins, 20 prop, 35 2nd row approx)
17 Donoghoe (60 mins at lock from 20-80min in one stint)
18. Kaufusi/Knowles/Rasmussen/Symonds whoever deserves it on merit, but limited minutes if any barring injury
19. Fuller/Lavender/Nonu, probably Fuller until Lavender is ready and Hammer switches to centre and Bostock to wing if Fuller has to come on?

That team can win the comp if we stay healthy and that's assuming we lose Flegler AND don't replace him - and if that's the case and we let him go early, we should front-load either Herbie or Bostock's contract with the extra money if we somehow keep both, or front load Katoa's extension money to ease the burden on the cap in future seasons if we only keep one.

If we got a marquee middle that would be great but short of an early release for Leota there's no one i'd really want to pay 900k a season for, I legitimately think we can spend the Flegler money elsewhere which either means money for both Herbie and Bostock or more likely money to keep Herbie and then front load Katoa's contract extension with a lump sum in 2027 say 600k extra so he can take 200k less in in 2028-2030 to give us more cap space moving forward and then the future year savings go towards upgrading and extending Plath and Donoghoe next year as well

If the Finefuiaki middle idea doesn't work, then just slot in one of Kaufusi, Knowles, Rasmussen or Symonds into that bench forward role where they just play one 20-25 minute stint and have Pouniu or Lemuelu on the bench on merit with Finefuiaki in the second row as per usual - the logical candidate would be Kaufusi at first to just play 20 minutes while Plath is off, unless age has taken everything he has left in the off season, and when one of the rookies is ready they take his spot at some point during the season probably. Knowles ideally just plays as injury cover/depth when a starting forward is out.
 
I would much rather have Bostock and Herbie in the side and pay a rookie forward the minimum than have Utoikumanu on close to a million

I'd absolutely be interested in Utoikumanu but he is not the marquee player that takes a team's pack to dominating

If we're spending the Flegler money on a prop and could get Moses Leota right now, then sure, absolutely - but Stefano even though he's good isn't that guy and by the time Leota will be available he'll be too old to pay marquee money for.

Sua probably gets the low minutes Flegler job done well enough if we also shift Plath into the middle for most of his minutes and he just does 20 at lock and Donoghoe does 60 at lock and then we can potentially see if Finefuiaki or Lemuelu (probably Finefuiaki) can switch to the middle to accommodate Pouniu and boost our pack as well

The Storm forward pack was outright horrific this year to the point their elite spine couldn't even do anything. I'd probably rather Safiti, Willison or Leota if we were going after a marquee middle but Leota and Safiti are age risks obviously, I think it makes more sense we develop our existing middles and have a truly spectacular 1-7, the Knights probably win the comp with that model with their starting halfback injured this year if Safiti and Mooney hadn't also been injured for the final, they only lost by 1 with both of their best props out and with an obviously weak forward pack for a grand final side.

If we can get Stefano on 600k a season then absolutely but I have a feeling he'll get closer to 1m a season and that is a disaster for what you're getting imo

Assuming we stay healthy and Flegler does secure an early release, i'd have our middles look something like

8. Gilbert and 10. Su'a and 13. Plath (for first 20 minutes, Donoghoe plays 60mins lock)

When we roll subs, Donoghoe comes on for Plath and goes to lock for the rest of the game for the impact that worked so well in 2026 playing 60mins there, Molo comes on for Gilbert to keep an experienced middle out there and Finefuiaki/Lemuelu come on for Su'a (if either can work as a middle)

so our middles look something like 8. Molo 10. Finefuiaki and 13. Donoghoe

When we roll subs again, Plath comes back as soon as possible and goes to prop to do the max minutes he's capable of I assume 60ish, Finefuiaki slides out to second row to play 60ish mins and whichever second rower needs to come off to accommodate out of Lemuelu and Pouniu comes off

So then we have 8. Molo, 10 Plath, 13 Donoghoe for a while

Then Molo subs off for Gilbert's second stint so they've done ~45mins for Gilbert and ~35mins for Molo at prop having one on at all times

So then the middle is 8. Gilbert 10 Plath 13 Donoghoe for the rest of the game unless injury/fatigue means we either need to bring Su'a back for a second stint or use our unused bench forward or Finefuaki more middle mins and both second rowers play 80

We could also switch roles with Molo starting and finishing and Gilbert doing the middle portion of the game, whichever rotation the coach thinks is better.

So our side looks like

I think that's a pretty damn amazing side at full strength without having to add a middle AND that's with having let Flegler go early, obviously he gets a spot still if he's staying one more year - so it would look something like

1. Hammer
2. Cobbo
3. Herbie
4. Bostock
5. Naufahu
6. Williams
7. Katoa
8. Gilbert/Molo (they play exactly 80 between them)
9. JMK
10. Su'a (plays one 20-25min stint for now)
11. Lemuelu
12. Pouniu
13. Plath (20 at lock, 40ish at prop)

14. Fineganofo (or Schneider if he isn't ready) to cover halves and hooker
15. Gilbert/Molo (they play exactly 80 between them)
16. Finefuiaki (plays ~55mins, 20 prop, 35 2nd row approx)
17 Donoghoe (60 mins at lock from 20-80min in one stint)
18. Kaufusi/Knowles/Rasmussen/Symonds whoever deserves it on merit, but limited minutes if any barring injury
19. Fuller/Lavender/Nonu, probably Fuller until Lavender is ready and Hammer switches to centre and Bostock to wing if Fuller has to come on?

That team can win the comp if we stay healthy and that's assuming we lose Flegler AND don't replace him - and if that's the case and we let him go early, we should front-load either Herbie or Bostock's contract with the extra money if we somehow keep both, or front load Katoa's extension money to ease the burden on the cap in future seasons if we only keep one.

If we got a marquee middle that would be great but short of an early release for Leota there's no one i'd really want to pay 900k a season for, I legitimately think we can spend the Flegler money elsewhere which either means money for both Herbie and Bostock or more likely money to keep Herbie and then front load Katoa's contract extension with a lump sum in 2027 say 600k extra so he can take 200k less in in 2028-2030 to give us more cap space moving forward and then the future year savings go towards upgrading and extending Plath and Donoghoe next year as well

If the Finefuiaki middle idea doesn't work, then just slot in one of Kaufusi, Knowles, Rasmussen or Symonds into that bench forward role where they just play one 20-25 minute stint and have Pouniu or Lemuelu on the bench on merit with Finefuiaki in the second row as per usual - the logical candidate would be Kaufusi at first to just play 20 minutes while Plath is off, unless age has taken everything he has left in the off season, and when one of the rookies is ready they take his spot at some point during the season probably. Knowles ideally just plays as injury cover/depth when a starting forward is out.
what does a marquee forwards stats And pay look like he has way better figures than our guys on 900k hes better than molo and su'a aint there yet , we loose thomas f who we gretting that has stronger stats ?

stefano worth everything hes on if the toms are on 900k hes rep prop so yeah dont see him getting 600k when i would say molos on bout that
 
I would much rather have Bostock and Herbie in the side and pay a rookie forward the minimum than have Utoikumanu on close to a million

I'd absolutely be interested in Utoikumanu but he is not the marquee player that takes a team's pack to dominating

If we're spending the Flegler money on a prop and could get Moses Leota right now, then sure, absolutely - but Stefano even though he's good isn't that guy and by the time Leota will be available he'll be too old to pay marquee money for.

Sua probably gets the low minutes Flegler job done well enough if we also shift Plath into the middle for most of his minutes and he just does 20 at lock and Donoghoe does 60 at lock and then we can potentially see if Finefuiaki or Lemuelu (probably Finefuiaki) can switch to the middle to accommodate Pouniu and boost our pack as well

The Storm forward pack was outright horrific this year to the point their elite spine couldn't even do anything. I'd probably rather Safiti, Willison or Leota if we were going after a marquee middle but Leota and Safiti are age risks obviously, I think it makes more sense we develop our existing middles and have a truly spectacular 1-7, the Knights probably win the comp with that model with their starting halfback injured this year if Safiti and Mooney hadn't also been injured for the final, they only lost by 1 with both of their best props out and with an obviously weak forward pack for a grand final side.

If we can get Stefano on 600k a season then absolutely but I have a feeling he'll get closer to 1m a season and that is a disaster for what you're getting imo

Assuming we stay healthy and Flegler does secure an early release, i'd have our middles look something like

8. Gilbert and 10. Su'a and 13. Plath (for first 20 minutes, Donoghoe plays 60mins lock)

When we roll subs, Donoghoe comes on for Plath and goes to lock for the rest of the game for the impact that worked so well in 2026 playing 60mins there, Molo comes on for Gilbert to keep an experienced middle out there and Finefuiaki/Lemuelu come on for Su'a (if either can work as a middle)

so our middles look something like 8. Molo 10. Finefuiaki and 13. Donoghoe

When we roll subs again, Plath comes back as soon as possible and goes to prop to do the max minutes he's capable of I assume 60ish, Finefuiaki slides out to second row to play 60ish mins and whichever second rower needs to come off to accommodate out of Lemuelu and Pouniu comes off

So then we have 8. Molo, 10 Plath, 13 Donoghoe for a while

Then Molo subs off for Gilbert's second stint so they've done ~45mins for Gilbert and ~35mins for Molo at prop having one on at all times

So then the middle is 8. Gilbert 10 Plath 13 Donoghoe for the rest of the game unless injury/fatigue means we either need to bring Su'a back for a second stint or use our unused bench forward or Finefuaki more middle mins and both second rowers play 80

We could also switch roles with Molo starting and finishing and Gilbert doing the middle portion of the game, whichever rotation the coach thinks is better.

So our side looks like

I think that's a pretty damn amazing side at full strength without having to add a middle AND that's with having let Flegler go early, obviously he gets a spot still if he's staying one more year - so it would look something like

1. Hammer
2. Cobbo
3. Herbie
4. Bostock
5. Naufahu
6. Williams
7. Katoa
8. Gilbert/Molo (they play exactly 80 between them)
9. JMK
10. Su'a (plays one 20-25min stint for now)
11. Lemuelu
12. Pouniu
13. Plath (20 at lock, 40ish at prop)

14. Fineganofo (or Schneider if he isn't ready) to cover halves and hooker
15. Gilbert/Molo (they play exactly 80 between them)
16. Finefuiaki (plays ~55mins, 20 prop, 35 2nd row approx)
17 Donoghoe (60 mins at lock from 20-80min in one stint)
18. Kaufusi/Knowles/Rasmussen/Symonds whoever deserves it on merit, but limited minutes if any barring injury
19. Fuller/Lavender/Nonu, probably Fuller until Lavender is ready and Hammer switches to centre and Bostock to wing if Fuller has to come on?

That team can win the comp if we stay healthy and that's assuming we lose Flegler AND don't replace him - and if that's the case and we let him go early, we should front-load either Herbie or Bostock's contract with the extra money if we somehow keep both, or front load Katoa's extension money to ease the burden on the cap in future seasons if we only keep one.

If we got a marquee middle that would be great but short of an early release for Leota there's no one i'd really want to pay 900k a season for, I legitimately think we can spend the Flegler money elsewhere which either means money for both Herbie and Bostock or more likely money to keep Herbie and then front load Katoa's contract extension with a lump sum in 2027 say 600k extra so he can take 200k less in in 2028-2030 to give us more cap space moving forward and then the future year savings go towards upgrading and extending Plath and Donoghoe next year as well

If the Finefuiaki middle idea doesn't work, then just slot in one of Kaufusi, Knowles, Rasmussen or Symonds into that bench forward role where they just play one 20-25 minute stint and have Pouniu or Lemuelu on the bench on merit with Finefuiaki in the second row as per usual - the logical candidate would be Kaufusi at first to just play 20 minutes while Plath is off, unless age has taken everything he has left in the off season, and when one of the rookies is ready they take his spot at some point during the season probably. Knowles ideally just plays as injury cover/depth when a starting forward is out.
That is probably the ideal situation and rotation that we all imagine. Very good for our anxiety as well that our backups on the bench leave literally nothing to be desired and our hardworking utility blokes can shift around without upsetting the balance much at all.

For kuli to prop in not basing it on the world cup just gone. I was thinking it a while ago when Keaon got into the NSW side a year after being swapped from the back to the front row, and then of course this year he is a world cup kangaroo as well. Kuli might have told Woolf he doesn't want to, but it passes the eye test, and he finished this year in the top 10 for tackles made and is a big rumbling ball runner too. If flegler is surviving 20 minutes, barely, then kuli could do a solid 30 or a very destructive 20. And of course we have all seen pouniu now and I don't remember seeing such a young kind of lanky looking forward have so much strength in post contact. He will obviously develop but the platform is good to go. If he has a big pre season alongside kuli and this flegler thing means he is gone then even if kuli isn't really a prop yet I just can't see where we go backwards doing this, especially since woolfy does a great job getting our boys to believe and then develop their game anyway. Gilbert for example I think was our best middle last year and the gossip here was he wouldn't fit in anywhere because the backrow and lock was set in stone. Now he is a prototype modern prop who is not as out of place as the bloke with a bigger name in the forwards who somehow earned an origin spot.
 
Molo is on only slightly more than half of the money that Stefano would want though mr_c and Flegler is nowhere near a 900k a season player post injury which is why we haven't been using him for big mins and why we are going to be letting him go to the Cows or wherever

Stefano is at the lower end of marquee middles for sure though in that he is what maybe the 10th-15th best prop in the comp?

Off the top of my head players above or at least as good as him

Haas
Carrigan even though his form is iffy
Willison
Tino
Plath if he moves to the middle this season and he should do most of his mins there this year
Fisher Harris
Leota
Koloamatagi
AFB
Safiti
Murray and Yeo and Clark although I guess they are locks more than middles
Lindsey Smith is close
Ford
Barnett
Whyte
Collins
Cotter is close
May is close
Tapine if we count him as a prop not lock
Maybe the Couchmans depending how they develop this season

Looking at that list and discounting the players who are primarily locks not props I'd say maybe we can get Stefano to being about the 15th best prop in the comp... Is that really worth the 1m a season he will probably want if it was 700k a season absolutely and probably even 800k but I just don't think his on field impact will be what that price point warrants
 
Molo is on only slightly more than half of the money that Stefano would want though mr_c and Flegler is nowhere near a 900k a season player post injury which is why we haven't been using him for big mins and why we are going to be letting him go to the Cows or wherever

Stefano is at the lower end of marquee middles for sure though in that he is what maybe the 10th-15th best prop in the comp?

Off the top of my head players above or at least as good as him

Haas
Carrigan even though his form is iffy
Willison
Tino
Plath if he moves to the middle this season and he should do most of his mins there this year
Fisher Harris
Leota
Koloamatagi
AFB
Safiti
Murray and Yeo and Clark although I guess they are locks more than middles
Lindsey Smith is close
Ford
Barnett
Whyte
Collins
Cotter is close
May is close
Tapine if we count him as a prop not lock
Maybe the Couchmans depending how they develop this season

Looking at that list and discounting the players who are primarily locks not props I'd say maybe we can get Stefano to being about the 15th best prop in the comp... Is that really worth the 1m a season he will probably want if it was 700k a season absolutely and probably even 800k but I just don't think his on field impact will be what that price point warrants
Koloamatagi would have been the one if we had a time machine to see what would happen with flegler and signed him a year ago. Perfect for our culture and he's not a big slow bopper, almost everyone else on that list is either too expensive to pull away from their club or too old to take a chance. Keaon with toms money for three years would have been fantastic. Watching how he handled Leniu trying to start something is a fair bit of what I'm talking about he's not an idiot even though he is very good and tough.
 
Molo is on only slightly more than half of the money that Stefano would want though mr_c and Flegler is nowhere near a 900k a season player post injury which is why we haven't been using him for big mins and why we are going to be letting him go to the Cows or wherever

Stefano is at the lower end of marquee middles for sure though in that he is what maybe the 10th-15th best prop in the comp?

Off the top of my head players above or at least as good as him

Haas
Carrigan even though his form is iffy
Willison
Tino
Plath if he moves to the middle this season and he should do most of his mins there this year
Fisher Harris
Leota
Koloamatagi
AFB
Safiti
Murray and Yeo and Clark although I guess they are locks more than middles
Lindsey Smith is close
Ford
Barnett
Whyte
Collins
Cotter is close
May is close
Tapine if we count him as a prop not lock
Maybe the Couchmans depending how they develop this season

Looking at that list and discounting the players who are primarily locks not props I'd say maybe we can get Stefano to being about the 15th best prop in the comp... Is that really worth the 1m a season he will probably want if it was 700k a season absolutely and probably even 800k but I just don't think his on field impact will be what that price point warrants
so we pay the senior props hear 500k and 900k and no much for seb

so if its not stefano then who , as the guys we have prop wise currently minus thom would be in the bottom 20 props

you compared him to the middles who ofcourse that are do the big minutes

to get a senior prop thats test level if you not paying them big coin whether it Stefano or another they will do more than our current guys


you rate him so low my question is we loose ( thom f covert fin and if that dont who we look to ) as we will need get him now and with thom going ( options going be slim ) we would need find one that can do something thats worth 800k plus a season
 
Why do we have to pay a prop 800k a season unless there's a marquee prop worthy of that? We won't get Stefano for 800k either, more like 1m if we could get Stefano on 750k a season sure i'd be all for signing him but there is no chance of that

He supposedly took a pay cut to go to the Storm on 600k a season but they'll have to upgrade him to keep him and realistically he will be getting 900k+ offers

I'd pay Haas 1.3m a season in half a second if he was available. There's only a handful of elite props younger than 27, Haas is obviously top of the list but there is daylight between him and the next group in terms of output. As far as younger props go that can be signed long term the next tier after Haas is probably Tino (signed long term to the Titans and on overs), Plath who already plays for us assuming he does most of his minutes at prop once Donoghoe comes on as our main lock moving forward and Naufahu Whyte who isn't going to leave the Roosters.

Willison is an option for sure, and then Stefano but I don't think they're quite at the level of Whyte/Plath/Tino group that are probably worth 1m a season

Leniu is too much of a mental basket case and plays too few minutes for marquee money

Lindsey Smith is good but won't be leaving Penrith realistically especially after they let Henry go

The next best young middles are probably the Couchmans and they're not 1m a season players yet as good as they are

Other than that the middles worth 1m a season in impact would be very risky signings (Leota, Tapine, Fisher-Harris) due to age and i'm not sure the others are quite in that top tier anymore (AFB, Carrigan who wouldn't leave the Broncos anyway, Safiti etc)

If we're going after a marquee middle then I guess with age and who is available, Stefano is probably the second best option after Willison, but realistically he isn't worth 1m+ a season I don't think. You probably want a top 10 prop in the comp for that at least and I think Stefano is probably more like 15th best or so

Plus we have to pay Plath and Donoghoe next year and that will eat up most of our budget for marquee middles assuming we sign Plath as a prop who does the non-Donoghoe lock minutes and Donoghoe as the main lock

I think we try and keep both Bostock and Herbie and assuming the median outcome of lose Bostock and keep Herbie and move Flegler on, we front-load some of Katoa's contract extension money in 2027 with the leftover cap space from Flegler if we let him go early, then save the Flegler and Kaufusi retirement money to extend and upgrade Plath and Donoghoe next year

If we keep both Herbie and Bostock we definitely need to not sign anyone else and bank the Flegler money and even if we lose one of them I would still not replace him with a marquee middle to give us better cap flexibility - the only exception might be if we could get an early release for Leota while he is still good to try and go all in to win the comp in 2027, but there is no way the Panthers are releasing him early and by 2028/29 it's just too much of an age risk that your 1.1-1.2m a season middle starts getting washed.

The way our squad is set up we can only really afford to pay a couple of middles in the medium term and paying Stefano or Willison would likely lead to us not being able to keep both Plath and Donoghoe long term as well as Katoa - the two middles we pay should be Plath and Donoghoe and we fill in the rest of the middles with developed young talent and mid range starting props like Molo and Gilbert who can do the job competently on mid range money but aren't marquee.

I think there is a massive difference between paying 1.2m a season for Haas or Fisher-Harris vs paying 1m a season for a Stefano level player - it's really worth that extra money to get that player that can carry the team on his back but the difference between Stefano and say a Max King or Francis Molo player just isn't big enough to warrant paying Stefano marquee money, otherwise you just need guys who will not get beaten as a pack and if you have an elite and expensive 1-7+9+13 which we do they can win the games as long as the pack does an okay job - the other option is go all in on the pack as the Warriors did, but then you just lack the depth and talent in the spine and backs to actually win the comp as we saw last year. We saw it with the Raiders the year before too, they were all pack and won the minor premiership, but couldn't win a finals game when it counted.

Don't get me wrong I think Stefano would make us a better football side but at the money we'd pay for him I think it would be a substantial mistake to pay him the 1m a season it would likely take to land him

If i'm wrong and we can get him on 800k a season to replace Flegler, cool, i'd be all for signing him but I doubt he'll come that cheap and even then i'd take Bostock and a rookie forward over Stefano and a rookie back probably.
 
Last edited:
Why do we have to pay a prop 800k a season unless there's a marquee prop worthy of that? We won't get Stefano for 800k either, more like 1m if we could get Stefano on 750k a season sure i'd be all for signing him but there is no chance of that

He supposedly took a pay cut to go to the Storm on 600k a season but they'll have to upgrade him to keep him and realistically he will be getting 900k+ offers

I'd pay Haas 1.3m a season in half a second if he was available. There's only a handful of elite props younger than 27, Haas is obviously top of the list but there is daylight between him and the next group in terms of output. As far as younger props go that can be signed long term the next tier after Haas is probably Tino (signed long term to the Titans and on overs), Plath who already plays for us assuming he does most of his minutes at prop once Donoghoe comes on as our main lock moving forward and Naufahu Whyte who isn't going to leave the Roosters.

Willison is an option for sure, and then Stefano but I don't think they're quite at the level of Whyte/Plath/Tino group that are probably worth 1m a season

Leniu is too much of a mental basket case and plays too few minutes for marquee money

Lindsey Smith is good but won't be leaving Penrith realistically especially after they let Henry go

The next best young middles are probably the Couchmans and they're not 1m a season players yet as good as they are

Other than that the middles worth 1m a season in impact would be very risky signings (Leota, Tapine, Fisher-Harris) due to age and i'm not sure the others are quite in that top tier anymore (AFB, Carrigan who wouldn't leave the Broncos anyway, Safiti etc)

If we're going after a marquee middle then I guess with age and who is available, Stefano is probably the second best option after Willison, but realistically he isn't worth 1m+ a season I don't think. You probably want a top 10 prop in the comp for that at least and I think Stefano is probably more like 15th best or so

Plus we have to pay Plath and Donoghoe next year and that will eat up most of our budget for marquee middles assuming we sign Plath as a prop who does the non-Donoghoe lock minutes and Donoghoe as the main lock

I think we try and keep both Bostock and Herbie and assuming the median outcome of lose Bostock and keep Herbie and move Flegler on, we front-load some of Katoa's contract extension money in 2027 with the leftover cap space from Flegler if we let him go early, then save the Flegler and Kaufusi retirement money to extend and upgrade Plath and Donoghoe next year

If we keep both Herbie and Bostock we definitely need to not sign anyone else and bank the Flegler money and even if we lose one of them I would still not replace him with a marquee middle to give us better cap flexibility - the only exception might be if we could get an early release for Leota while he is still good to try and go all in to win the comp in 2027, but there is no way the Panthers are releasing him early and by 2028/29 it's just too much of an age risk that your 1.1-1.2m a season middle starts getting washed.

The way our squad is set up we can only really afford to pay a couple of middles in the medium term and paying Stefano or Willison would likely lead to us not being able to keep both Plath and Donoghoe long term as well as Katoa - the two middles we pay should be Plath and Donoghoe and we fill in the rest of the middles with developed young talent and mid range starting props like Molo and Gilbert who can do the job competently on mid range money but aren't marquee.

I think there is a massive difference between paying 1.2m a season for Haas or Fisher-Harris vs paying 1m a season for a Stefano level player - it's really worth that extra money to get that player that can carry the team on his back but the difference between Stefano and say a Max King or Francis Molo player just isn't big enough to warrant paying Stefano marquee money, otherwise you just need guys who will not get beaten as a pack and if you have an elite and expensive 1-7+9+13 which we do they can win the games as long as the pack does an okay job - the other option is go all in on the pack as the Warriors did, but then you just lack the depth and talent in the spine and backs to actually win the comp as we saw last year. We saw it with the Raiders the year before too, they were all pack and won the minor premiership, but couldn't win a finals game when it counted.

Don't get me wrong I think Stefano would make us a better football side but at the money we'd pay for him I think it would be a substantial mistake to pay him the 1m a season it would likely take to land him

If i'm wrong and we can get him on 800k a season to replace Flegler, cool, i'd be all for signing him but I doubt he'll come that cheap and even then i'd take Bostock and a rookie forward over Stefano and a rookie back probably.
I agree on the value of Stefano. Unless he is unhappy in Melbourne and will take another low pay day for us I don't see the output and dollars balancing. Plus he really doesn't seem like he would fit in with our boys, which actually matters in hard games. That being said the entire market around props is beyond strangled. We can cross our fingers that our own guys step up and own it like elite props do
 
this is why we cant be paying centres 1 mil plus.

Prop is a premium position.

Cant skimp on prop and pay top dollar at centre. Its a disaster waiting to happen.

It will be like parking a ferrari in the garage and not driving it. Because our forward pack arent going forward.

Had we had 1 prop this year that dominated. We would have sat the comp in.
 
I get what you're saying but Stefano is not a Payne Haas or a James Fisher-Harris

and it would have meant no Bostock or Herbie presumably this year, which would have slightly hurt the attack

Basically if Flegler was having a Payne Haas season, yes, maybe we could have won the comp in 2026 - to be honest if we didn't throw that intercept that led to the first try and went over in the corner ourselves there's a good chance we win the grand final with the Knights pack decimated and we're premiers right now.

Centres are a pretty underrated position in terms of importance

As an ex Titans fan it I can say it is an absolute disaster to have centres who pose no threat in attack or who can't defend. A very good portion of the Titans issue for years is they haven't had a good centre since Hurrell's prime, now Jojo is playing centre despite primarily being a winger out of necessity. They also struggled at hooker and in the halves which is more important but it was the centres letting in try after try after try off horrendous centre defensive reads year after year, that's something we didn't have to deal with at all in 2026 and the amazing attack is obviously a bonus too.

It's a balancing act but it's also not like our pack is terrible. Our 1-7 is arguably equal best in the comp, then only really Knowles and Flegler didn't perform to at least an average level in 2026 and in Flegler's case it's more his body post injury letting him down than actual skillset and Plath and Donoghoe were consistently elite, Donoghoe was at worst the third best lock in the comp and Plath is a top 10 middle forward when he's playing there and is also a rep level lock, although we're better with him in the middle and Donoghoe at lock

The biggest thing to not do is panic and overpay for a forward that doesn't deliver

Tino has been good but hasn't justified his paycheck at the Titans, Fotuaika has been a disaster for the last couple years after being decent initially on good money and then the Titans made the mistake of paying marquee money to Fermor after the injury ruined his mobility - before that he was a marquee level second rower. They also paid Fifita marquee second rower money and while at his best in attack he is very good, he is a defensive liability at times and can be on the lazy side work rate wise and you can't have that in 1m+ players

I would equate the Fermor contract despite them playing different positions with the idea of extending Flegler on 900k a season. The injury has ruined him and he's on marquee money so you have to let him go and likely another club will overpay for him 'because he's an origin player'

As it stands Flegler was giving us 300-400k a season in output on 900k. You just can't have that

I'm worried Stefano would give us 600k a season in output on 1m if we were to sign him

I actually think having elite centres is slightly more important than having elite wingers, as long as your wingers are not short or slow. Naufahu will do a fine job but won't cost big bucks and while Cobbo is an excellent player, i'd have let him go all day and plugged in an average winger to keep both elite centres if it came down to that

We will be fine if we lose one of the two of them assuming Lavender delivers as expected by 2028 but losing both would really, really hurt our ability to contend in the short term even if we added a marquee middle. I'm not sure even adding Payne Haas would get us to winning a comp if we lost both Herbie and Bostock, we can deal with losing one but not both.

The Warriors in 2026 are a perfect example of what a good pack can do if they don't have the elite 1-7 to go with it, they can get into good positions but they just can't pile on the points to beat good teams when it counts and they were never going to win the comp because of that. Halasima was probably their best outside back this season and he only played a handful of games there because they repurposed him from being a second rower and obviously their halves combinations are terrible other than Metcalf who couldn't stay healthy and Tanah Boyd is an absolute myth because he happened to have 3 good games behind a dominant forward pack

I agree that as amazing as Bostock is we can't pay him 1m a season, but 850-900k is fine imo with the cap going up and we absolutely can pay Herbie a little over 1m a season, he brings that much value to the side giving us a devastating left edge in attack with Cobbo and being probably the safest centre in the game defensively

I know it sounds ridiculous but if you can get both of them for a combined flat 2m a season i'm doing it with the cap going up, and maybe even a bit over that if there are no ratchet clauses since the cap is going up in 2028
 
He does more than any of our props stats wise and with woolf knowing him he get best outta him take.if we got Wilson he ain't a senior prop but will demand it yet but he's perfect example if. He doesn't. Preform at another club his value goes down


So who is out there that is going do big stats
 
He does more than any of our props stats wise and with woolf knowing him he get best outta him take.if we got Wilson he ain't a senior prop but will demand it yet but he's perfect example if. He doesn't. Preform at another club his value goes down


So who is out there that is going do big stats
I would almost rather Willison despite him not being senior because senior premiership winning prop almost adds $200k to your actual playing value. Willison I think would suit our culture a little more, he seems pretty humble despite playing for the Broncs, and he doesn't have to be the alpha, just a big reliable bloke. For the fire and brimstone we have Gilbert and no one argues with him on the field and he keeps our boys in line, something I really like about him. Stefano I suspect would feel disrespected by that, where Willison being a bit younger and still quite young can accept that he isn't the top dog even if he is the biggest.

Issue is that Willison is young and has no reason at all to not get a shit tonne of cash at PNG.
 
I would almost rather Willison despite him not being senior because senior premiership winning prop almost adds $200k to your actual playing value. Willison I think would suit our culture a little more, he seems pretty humble despite playing for the Broncs, and he doesn't have to be the alpha, just a big reliable bloke. For the fire and brimstone we have Gilbert and no one argues with him on the field and he keeps our boys in line, something I really like about him. Stefano I suspect would feel disrespected by that, where Willison being a bit younger and still quite young can accept that he isn't the top dog even if he is the biggest.

Issue is that Willison is young and has no reason at all to not get a shit tonne of cash at PNG.
no butr the issue i see with wilson aint png its the fact broncos wont give up with out a fight so we would need pay him well overs to get him
 
Top